Kristen Stewart. I Want to Like Her, But…

Katie Baker —  May 1, 2012

OK, so I just saw the full trailer for Snow White and the Huntsman, and at first glance it looks great! I would typically be really excited about this film, but Kristen Stewart is playing Snow White. I just don’t understand what Hollywood sees in this girl. I get that she is stunningly beautiful and thin, which is all you really need nowadays to make a name for yourself, but she is not leading lady material.

Now, I am sure off-camera she is a wonderful person. She’s driven and very focused. I also think that her natural awkwardness is endearing, but what I think a great actor should have is a very strong and wide emotional range, and she just doesn’t have it.

There is no comparison

I’ve seen all the Twilights…so far (seriously, make it stop already!), and I understand why they hired her on the first one. She’s young and clumsy and she definitely looked the part, but as the story progressed, Kristen was not able to capture the intense emotions that the story required.

I’ve been hearing her compared to Jennifer Lawrence, who plays Katniss in the Hunger Games, and I think this is absurd. There is no comparison! Jennifer Lawrence’s performance was fantastic. I believed in her devotion to her sister, her fear just before going into the games, and her devastation when Rue died. She sold it, and I bought it! Kristen would not have been able to pull that off.

Benefit of the Doubt

Now, here’s the part where I try to make nice with K-Stew. Like I said, she is stunning. I mean seriously, I want her face. I have seen her grow through the Twilight Series and I actually thought she was pretty good in The Runaways. She was awful in Adventureland, but what I am saying is that I see potential. She’s getting better.

I want to believe she can play Snow White in Snow White and the Huntsman. I think this is going to be an awesome take on the classic story, and visually it looks gorgeous. I just worry she will be as flat and emotionless as she is in every other role she’s played.

But, I will be giving her the benefit of the doubt because I really do want to like her.

What do you think of Kristen Stewart as Snow White?

Katie Baker

Posts Twitter

Katie was born and raised on the beautiful islands of Hawaii. She thinks all dogs are boys, all cats are girls, and all giraffes are French.
  • delyssa

    I think you’re just being nice when you say she’s stunning.  I was all excited for Snow White and the Hunstman because I simply loooooooove Snow White (she’s always have been my favorite Disney Princess and my favorite Grimm fairytale), but not so much now that I know KS is playing my beloved Snow White.  I don’t know if I will see it in theaters or not, I do think Charlize Theron’s performance as the Queen will be amazing though.

    • Katie

      I don’t know. I think this a cool take on Snow White and if you get past KStews surly attitude and greasy hair she is gorgeous. I’m excited for it!

  • Jess

    I’m actually INTENSELY excited about this movie. At first, I wanted Mirror, Mirror to win the Snow White showdown. But SWATH has taken the lead. Charlize Theron is AWESOME. And the visuals look amazing. And the new Florence + the Machine song blows me away.

    Alright. Enough raving. I agree totally with you on everything you said. Except I liked her in Adventureland. But comparing her to Jennifer Lawrence IS insane. Who the heck is saying that? They crazy!!! :)

    • Katie

      I think it’ll be good. If nothing else it will be cool looking. I thought she was dull and lifeless is Adventureland. Kinda like she is in every movie she’s in. She is improving though so I’m going to hold on to hope that she won’t destroy SWATH.

  • http://MacedoniaFilms.com/ Dan Baker

    Why does she always look so mad? Was it something I said?

    • Katie

      Yes Dan. Always yes.

  • delyssa

    oh, no doubt it’s a cool take on Snow White, I just always thought Snow White should be pretty.  I know that’s mean to say, but I’m shallow enough to admit that I want good looking people in movies, but I’m not stupid enough to believe that anyone that is in a movie is “omg hot”.  

    • Katie

      Really? Cuz Chris Hemsworth is kinda omg.

      Not as hot as Dan Baker of course.

  • Cameo Renae

    I have to agree… When they chose Kristen to play Snow White I was like…crap!!! There goes the movie! All of her expressions are the same, and she has that same ”constipated” look most of the time. Plus, she looks like she’s angry at everyone around her.
    Don’t get me wrong… I absolutely LOVED Kristen in Zathura, and even Panic Room (if we want to go back that far). lol She was really good in those movies. Believable. But that was back when she was young and innocent.What happened to her?
    So yes, I am excited to watch Snow White and the Huntsman, but not so excited that Kristen is going to play the main character. I’ll probably be critiquing her facials during the whole movie… *sigh* (And I do think she’s very pretty. :)

    • Katie

      When her hair and makeup are done well, I think she’s a stunner. Maybe it’s that I always root for the underdog but I really want her to rock Snow White. I’m believing that she can do it. She has improved so much from the first Twilight. I’ll probably be disappointed in her performance but maybe all the huge special effects will hide her constipation. :)

    • Cameo Renae

      Yeah… Hopefully a new role will pull her out of the Bella character. She does have it in her… We shall see! :)

  • Pretentious Filmmaker

    Im not willing to count her out just yet. Pretty sure she’s hated being Bella and has phoned in most of those performances. I’ve been hearing good buzz about her chops in Huntsmen besides an actor is only as good as their director!

    • Katie

      I absolutely agree. I’ll be looking forward to your review.

  • delyssa

    is it bad that i had to google who  Chris Hemsworth is?  i really don’t care about movies or actors like i did when i was a youngin’.  then again, i don’t think i cared about anything but NSYNC at the time.

    • Katie

      So if Joey Fatone played the hunter in Snow White you would totally care about this movie, huh!

  • delyssa

    uh….duh!  he can be my hunter and i can be his snow white

  • Pingback: A Bad Lip Reading of Twilight | Macedonia Films